First-Time Fathers Have Period of High Psychological Risk

A growing amount of data is demonstrating that new fathers are likely to develop depression in the perinatal period. Anxiety and stress during fatherhood receive less research attention than do anxiety and stress during motherhood. 

Longitudinal data tracking the evolution of men’s mental health following the birth of the first child are even rarer, especially in the French population. Only two studies of the subject have been conducted. They were dedicated solely to paternal depression and limited to the first 4 months post partum. Better understanding of the risk in the population can not only help identify public health issues, but also aid in defining targeted preventive approaches.

French researchers in epidemiology and public health sought to expand our knowledge of the mental health trajectories of new fathers using 9 years of data from the CONSTANCES cohort. Within this cohort, participants filled out self-administered questionnaires annually. They declared their parental status and the presence of mental illnesses. They also completed questionnaires to assess mental health, such as the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale for depression and the General Health Questionnaire for depressive, anxious, and somatic disorders. Thresholds for each score were established to characterize the severity of symptoms. In addition, the researchers analyzed all factors (eg, sociodemographic, psychosocial, lifestyle, professional, family, or cultural) that potentially are associated with poor mental health and were available within the questionnaires. 

The study included 6299 men who had their first child and for whom at least one mental health measure was collected during the follow-up period. These men had an average age of 38 years at inclusion, 88% lived with a partner, and 85% were employed. Overall, 7.9% of this male cohort self-reported a mental illness during the study, with 5.6% of illnesses occurring before the child’s birth and 9.7% after. Anxiety affected 6.5% of the cohort, and it was more pronounced after the birth than before (7.8% after vs 4.9% before). 

The rate of clinically significant symptoms averaged 23.2% during the study period, increasing from 18.3% to 25.2% after the birth. The discrepancy between the self-declared diagnosis by new fathers and the symptom-related score highlights underreporting or insufficient awareness among men. 

After conducting a latent class analysis, the researchers identified three homogeneous subgroups of men who had comparable mental health trajectories over time. The first group (90.3% of the cohort) maintained a constant and low risk for mental illnesses. The second (4.1%) presented a high and generally constant risk over time. Finally, 5.6% of the cohort had a temporarily high risk in the 2-4 years surrounding the birth.

The risk factors associated with being at a transiently high risk for mental illness were, in order of descending significance, not having a job, having had at least one negative experience during childhood, forgoing healthcare for financial reasons, and being aged 35-39 years (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] between 3.01 and 1.61). The risk factors associated with a high and constant mental illness risk were, in order of descending significance, being aged 60 years or older, not having a job, not living with a partner, being aged 40-44 years, and having other children in the following years (AOR between 3.79 and 1.85). 

The authors noted that the risk factors for mental health challenges associated with fatherhood do not imply causality, the meaning of which would also need further study. They contended that French fathers, who on average are entitled to 2 weeks of paid paternity leave, may struggle to manage their time, professional responsibilities, and parenting duties. Consequently, they may experience dissatisfaction and difficulty seeking support, assistance, or a mental health diagnosis, especially in the face of a mental health risk to which they are less attuned than women.

This story was translated from Univadis France, which is part of the Medscape Professional Network, using several editorial tools, including AI, as part of the process. Human editors reviewed this content before publication.