The Dual Role of Illusion in Patient Care

“The Last Leaf” by O. Henry, published in 1907 in his collection The Trimmed Lamp and Other Stories of the Four Million, follows the story of “Johnsy” (Joanna), a young, impoverished artist who is seriously ill with pneumonia. Feeling hopeless, she believes she will die once the last leaf falls from the vine outside her window. Johnsy’s downstairs neighbor, Behrman, an aging artist considered a “failure in art,” creates an illusion to inspire her by painting a leaf on the wall, which helps restore Johnsy’s will to live. Ironically, though Johnsy recovers, Behrman — who braved the frigid damp night to paint the leaf — catches pneumonia and dies.

The story powerfully underscores the role of illusion in medicine, illustrating how it can deeply influence patient care, for better or worse.

Beneficial Uses of Illusion in Medicine

Placebo Effect: One of the clearest examples of a beneficial illusion in medicine is the placebo effect. When patients believe they are receiving effective treatment, even if it’s an inactive substance, they can experience real symptom relief. This highlights how a patient’s perception can lead to tangible physical and psychological improvements. Studies suggest that the placebo effect can alleviate pain, reduce anxiety, and even improve outcomes in various chronic conditions. This reflects how belief, or the “illusion” of treatment, can mobilize the body’s own resources for healing.

Therapeutic Communication: Physicians may also use illusion in communication, intentionally framing their words and actions to instill confidence and reassurance. For example, a physician may project calm and certainty in a serious diagnosis or downplay possible adverse effects to avoid overwhelming a patient with anxiety. This illusion of control and reassurance can help patients feel safer and less fearful, which can have positive effects on their overall treatment experience and may even enhance their recovery.

Environmental Illusions: In some healthcare settings, environments are designed to create comforting illusions. For instance, many hospitals use nature-inspired art, soothing lighting, and even virtual reality experiences to reduce patient stress and improve comfort. This illusion of being in a serene, non-clinical space can lower blood pressure and stress hormone levels, which are important for healing and recovery, particularly in high-stress environments like intensive care units.

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): While not an illusion in the traditional sense, CBT involves changing the way patients perceive and interpret their thoughts and experiences, allowing them to gain control over their reactions and break free from self-defeating patterns of behavior. By altering these perceptions, patients can reduce symptoms of depression and anxiety, effectively changing their mental states.

Hypnosis: During hypnosis, patients enter a deeply relaxed state and may experience changes in sensation, perception, and memory, which can be seen as a form of illusion. This altered state allows them to explore thoughts and feelings in a way that can lead to therapeutic benefits. For instance, hypnosis can aid in managing chronic pain by altering the patient’s perception of it, creating a situation that lessens the pain’s intensity. I experienced this firsthand years ago after sustaining a painful football injury. Just the anticipation of the emergency physician’s examination intensified my pain. With my consent, he hypnotized me, allowing him to manipulate my neck and shoulder to diagnose a broken collarbone, later confirmed by X-ray.

Detrimental Effects of Illusion in Medicine

Placebo Effect: The placebo effect acts as a double-edged sword — while it shows the powerful influence of mind on body and offers insights into non-medication-based healing mechanisms, it also complicates the clinical landscape, making it harder to assess true treatment efficacy and adding ethical layers to patient care and clinical trials. Psychiatric patients, especially those with conditions like depression and anxiety, tend to respond more favorably to placebos than patients with purely physiological illnesses. This robust placebo response can make it difficult to accurately measure the efficacy of psychiatric medications.

False Reassurance and Misdiagnosis: Sometimes, illusions can mislead both the patient and the clinician. Overly optimistic language or reassurance, if misused, may give patients a false sense of security. If a physician downplays symptoms or glosses over risks, patients might ignore early signs of complications or delay seeking necessary care. This illusion can ultimately delay proper diagnosis and treatment, leading to worse outcomes.

The Illusion of Certainty: In some cases, clinicians present diagnoses or prognoses with a degree of certainty that is not warranted, creating an illusion of absolute knowledge where ambiguity actually exists. This is particularly problematic in complex or poorly understood conditions, where the physician’s confidence might prevent patients from seeking second opinions or alternative therapies. Such certainty can also hinder shared decision-making, making patients feel less empowered to ask questions or express concerns.

Overuse of Diagnostic Technology: The illusion created by high-tech diagnostic tools can also mislead both patients and physicians. Advanced imaging and lab tests often produce detailed information that may not be clinically relevant, but they can create an illusion of “seeing something.” This can lead to overdiagnosis, where minor anomalies are treated as serious issues, or to an overreliance on tests rather than a holistic assessment of the patient. Both scenarios can cause unnecessary anxiety, lead to invasive procedures, or even cause harm from overtreatment.

A Delicate Balance

Just as Behrman’s painted leaf offers Johnsy the hope she needs to survive, illusions in medicine can inspire optimism and even trigger real physiological benefits. Yet, illusions also carry risks when they distort reality, leading to overconfidence, misdiagnosis, or lost opportunities for meaningful patient engagement. The story of “The Last Leaf” reminds us of the delicate balance in medicine between using illusions to foster hope and ensuring they do not mislead, as they hold both promise and responsibility within patient care. Clinicians must use this power wisely within the ethical framework of medical practice.

Arthur Lazarus, MD, MBA, is a former Doximity Fellow, a member of the editorial board of the American Association for Physician Leadership, and an adjunct professor of psychiatry at the Lewis Katz School of Medicine at Temple University in Philadelphia. He is the author of several books on narrative medicine, including Medicine on Fire: A Narrative Travelogue and Story Treasures: Medical Essays and Insights in the Narrative Tradition.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.