Vulvar Dermatoses: Ob.Gyn Collaboration With Dermatologists

Sarah Cigna, MD, sees patients every week with vulvovaginal pain and vulvar dermatoses. She’s an ob.gyn. with a focus on sexual health — often the first physician seen by patients with vulvar pain or itch — and she believes collaboration with dermatologists is essential, especially for complex cases in what she calls a neglected, data-poor area of medicine.

She also recommends that dermatologists have a good understanding of the vestibule, “one of the most important structures in vulvar medicine,” and that they become equipped to recognize generalized and localized causes of vulvar pain and/or itch.

“The problem is, we don’t talk about [vulvovaginal pain and itch]…it’s taboo and we’re not taught about it in medical school,” Cigna, assistant professor of obstetrics & gynecology at The George Washington University (GWU), Washington, DC, said in a grand rounds lecture held recently at the GWU School of Medicine and Health Sciences Department of Dermatology.

“There are dermatologists who don’t have much training in vulvar dermatology, and a lot of gyns don’t get as much training” as they should, she said in an interview after the lecture. “So who’s looking at people’s vulvar skin and figuring out what’s going on and giving them effective treatments and evidence-based education?”

Cigna and dermatologist Emily Murphy, MD, will be co-directors of a joint ob.gyn-dermatology Vulvar Dermatology Clinic at GWU that will be launched in 2025, with monthly clinics for particularly challenging cases where the etiology is unclear or treatment is ineffective. “We want to collaborate in a more systematic way and put our heads together and think creatively about what will improve patient care,” Cigna said in the interview.

Dermatologists have valuable expertise in the immunology and genetic factors involved in skin disorders, Cigna said. Moreover, Murphy, assistant professor of dermatology and director of the Vulvar Health Program at GWU, said in an interview, dermatologists “are comfortable in going to off-label systemic medications that ob.gyns may not use that often” and bring to the table expertise in various types of procedures.

Murphy recently trained with Melissa Mauskar, MD, associate of dermatology and obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Texas Southwestern, Dallas, and founder and director of the Gynecologic Dermatology Clinic there. “It’s so important for dermatologists to be involved. It just takes some extra training that residents aren’t getting right now,” said Murphy, a member of the newly formed Vulvar Dermatoses Research Consortium.

In her grand rounds lecture, Cigna offered pearls to dermatologists for approaching a history and exam and covered highlights of the diagnosis and treatment of various problems, from vulvar candida infections and lichen simplex chronicus to vulvar lichen sclerosus (LS), vulvar lichen planus (LP), vulvar Crohn’s disease, pudendal neuralgia, and pelvic floor muscle spasm, as well as the role of mast cell proliferation in vulvar issues.

Approaching the History and Exam

A comprehensive history covers the start, duration, and location of pain and/or itching as well as a detailed timeline (such as timing of potential causes, including injuries or births) and symptoms (such as burning, cutting, aching, and stinging). The question of whether pain “is on the outside, at the entrance, or deeper inside” is “crucial, especially for those in dermatology,” Cigna emphasized.

“And if you’re seeing a patient for a vulvar condition, please ask them about sex. Ask, is this affecting your sexual or intimate life with your partner because this can also give you a clue about what’s going on and how you can help them,” she told the audience of dermatologists.

Queries about trauma history (physical and emotional/verbal), competitive sports (such as daily cycling, equestrian, and heavy weight lifting), endometriosis/gynecologic surgery, connective tissue disorders (such as Ehler-Danlos syndrome), and irritable bowel syndrome are all potentially important to consider. It is important to ask about anxiety, depression, and obsessive-compulsive disorder, which do not cause — but are highly associated with — vulvar dermatoses, she said.

A surprisingly large number of people with vulvovaginal issues are being diagnosed with Ehler-Danlos syndrome, so “I’m always asking, are you hypermobile because this might be affecting the musculoskeletal system, which might be affecting the pelvis,” Cigna said. “Anything that affects the pelvis can affect the vulva as well.”

The pelvic examination should be “offered” rather than assumed to be part of the exam, as part of a trauma-informed approach that is crucial for earning trust, she advised. “Just saying, ‘we’re going to talk, and then I can offer you an exam if you like’…patients like it. It helps them feel safer and more open.”

Many diagnoses are differentiated by eliciting pain on the anterior vs the posterior half of the vulvar vestibule — the part of the vulva that lies between the labia minora and is composed of nonkeratinized tissue with embryonic origins in the endoderm. “If you touch on the keratinized skin (of the vulva) and they don’t have pain, but on the vestibule they do have pain, and there is no pain inside the vagina, this suggests there is a vestibular problem,” said Cigna.

Pain/tenderness isolated to the posterior half of the vestibule suggests a muscular cause, and pain in both the posterior and anterior parts of the vestibule suggests a cause that is more systemic or diffuse, which could be a result of a hormonal issue such as one related to oral contraceptives or decreased testosterone, or a nerve-related process.

Cigna uses gentle swipes of a Q-tip moistened with water or gel to examine the vulva rather than a poke or touch, with the exception being the posterior vestibule, which overlies muscle insertion sites. “Make sure to get a baseline in remote areas such as the inner thigh, and always distinguish between ‘scratchy/sensitive’ sensations and pain,” she said, noting the value of having the patient hold a mirror on her inner thigh.

Causes of Vulvar Itch: Infectious and Noninfectious

With vulvar candidiasis, a common infectious cause of vulvar itch, “you have to ask if they’re also itching on the inside because if you treat them with a topical and you don’t treat the vaginal yeast infection that may be co-occurring, they’ll keep reseeding their vulvar skin,” Cigna said, “and it will never be fully treated.”

Candida albicans is the most common cause of vulvar or vulvovaginal candidiasis, and resistance to antifungals has been rising. Non-albicans Candida “tends to have even higher resistance rates,” she said. Ordering a sensitivity panel along with the culture is helpful, but “comprehensive vaginal biome” panels are generally not useful. “It’s hard to correlate the information clinically,” she said, “and there’s not always a lot of information about susceptibilities, which is what I really like to know.”

Cigna’s treatments for vaginal infections include miconazole, terconazole, and fluconazole (and occasionally, itraconazole or voriconazole — a “decision we don’t take lightly”). Vulvar treatments include nystatin ointment, clotrimazole cream, and miconazole cream. Often, optimal treatment involves addressing “both inside and out,” she said, noting the importance of also killing yeast in undergarment fabric.

“In my experience, Diflucan [oral fluconazole] doesn’t treat persistent vulvar cutaneous skin yeast well, so while I might try Diflucan, I typically use something topical as well,” she said. “And with vaginal yeast, we do use boric acid from time to time, especially for non-albicans species because it tends to be a little more effective.”

Noninfectious causes of vulvar itch include allergic, neuropathic, and muscular causes, as well as autoimmune dermatoses and mast cell activation syndrome. Well known in dermatology are acute contact dermatitis and lichen simplex chronicus — both characterized by induration, thickening, and a “puffy” erythematous appearance, and worsening of pruritus at night. What may be less appreciated is the long list of implicated allergens, including Always menstrual pads made of a plastic-containing “dry weave” material, Cigna said. There are at least several cotton-only, low-preservative feminine products available on the market, she noted.

Common Autoimmune Vulvar Dermatoses: LS and LP

Vulvar LS has traditionally been thought to affect mainly prepubertal and postmenopausal women, but the autoimmune condition is now known to affect more reproductive-age people with vulvas than previously appreciated, Cigna said.

And notably, in an observational web-based study of premenopausal women (aged 18-50 years) with biopsy-confirmed vulvar LS, the leading symptom was not itch but dyspareunia and tearing with intercourse. This means “we’re missing people,” said Cigna, an author of the study. “We think the reason we’re not seeing itch as commonly in this population is that itch is likely mediated by the low estrogen state of pre- and postmenopausal people.”

(Vulvar LS also occurs in pregnancy, with symptoms that are either stable or decrease during pregnancy and increase in the postpartum period, as demonstrated in a recently published online survey.)

Patients with vulvar LS can present with hypopigmentation, lichenification, and scarring and architectural changes, the latter of which can involve clitoral phimosis, labial resorption, and narrowing of the introitus. (The vaginal mucosa is unaffected.) The presentation can be subtle, especially in premenopausal women, and differentiation between LS, vitiligo, and yeast is sometimes necessary.

A timely biopsy-driven definitive diagnosis is important because vulvar LS increases the risk for cancer if it’s not adequately treated and because long-term steroid use can affect the accuracy of pathology reports. “We really care about keeping this disease in remission as much as possible,” Cigna said. Experts in the field recommend long-term maintenance therapy with a mid-ultra-potent steroid one to three times/week or an alternative. “I’ve just started using ruxolitinib cream, a Janus kinase (JAK) inhibitor, and tacrolimus, a calcineurin inhibitor,” she said.

With vulvar LP, based on current evidence, the risk for malignant transformation is low, but “it crosses into the vagina and can cause vaginal adhesions, so if you’re diagnosing someone with lichen planus, you need to make sure you’re talking with them about dilators, and if you’re not comfortable, send them to [gyn],” she said.

The use of vulvoscopy is important for one’s ability to see the fine Wickham’s striae that often characterize vulvar LP, she noted. Medical treatments for vulvar LP include topical calcineurin inhibitors, high-potency steroids, and JAK inhibitors.

Surgical treatment of vulvar granuloma fissuratum caused by vulvar LS is possible (when the patient is in complete remission, to prevent koebnerization), with daily post-op application of clobetasol and retraction of tissues, noted Cigna, the author of a study on vulvar lysis of adhesions.

With both LS and LP, Cigna said, “don’t forget (consideration of) hormones” as an adjunctive treatment, especially in postmenopausal women. “Patients in a low hormone state will have more flares.”

Vulvar Crohn’s

“We all have to know how to look for this,” Cigna said. “Unilateral or asymmetric swelling is classic, but don’t rule out the diagnosis if you see symmetric swelling.” Patients also typically have linear “knife-like” fissures or ulcerations, the vulva “is very indurated,” and “swelling is so intense, the patients are miserable,” she said.

Vulvar Crohn’s disease may precede intestinal disease in 20%-30% of patients, so referral to a gastroenterologist — and ideally subsequent collaboration — is important, as vulvar manifestations are treated with systemic medications typical for Crohn’s.

A biopsy is required for diagnosis, and the pathologist should be advised to look for lichenified squamous mucosa with the Touton giant cell reaction. “Vulvar Crohn’s is a rare enough disorder that if you don’t have an experienced or informed pathologist looking at your specimen, they may miss it because they won’t be looking for it,” Cigna added in the interview. “You should be really clear about what you’re looking for.”

Neuropathic Itch, Pelvic Floor Muscle Spasm

Patients with pudendal neuralgia — caused by an injured, entrapped, or irritated pudendal nerve (originating from S2-S4) — typically present with chronic vulvar and pelvic pain that is often unprovoked and worsens with sitting. Itching upon touch is often another symptom, and some patients describe a foreign body sensation. The cause is often trauma (such as an accident or childbirth-related) as opposed to myofascial irritation, Cigna explained in her lecture.

“Your exam will be largely normal, with no skin findings, so patients will get sent away if you don’t know to look for pudendal neuralgia by pressing on the pudendal nerve or doing (or referring for) a diagnostic nerve block,” Cigna added in the interview.

Persistent genital arousal disorder (PGAD) is “more global” in that it can also originate not only from the pudendal nerve but also from nerve roots higher in the spine or even from the brain. “People feel a sense of arousal, but some describe it as an itch,” Cigna said in her lecture, referring to a 2021 consensus document on PGAD/genito-pelvic dysesthesia by the International Society for the Study of Women’s Sexual Health as a valuable resource for understanding and managing the condition.

Diagnosis and treatment usually start with a pudendal nerve block with a combination of steroid and anesthetic. If this does not relieve arousal/itching, the next step may be an MRI to look higher in the spine.

Pelvic Floor Muscle Spasm

Vulvar pain, skin itching, and irritation can be symptoms of pelvic floor muscle spasm. “Oftentimes people come to me and say, ‘I have a dermatologic problem,’” Cigna said. “The skin may look red and erythematous, but it’s probably more likely a muscle problem when you’re not finding anything, and no amount of steroid will help the itch go away when the problem lies underneath.”

Co-occurring symptoms can include vaginal dryness, clitoral pain, urethral discomfort, bladder pain/irritation, increased urgency, constipation, and anal fissures. The first-line treatment approach is pelvic floor therapy.

“Pelvic floor therapy is not just for incontinence. It’s also for pain and discomfort from muscles,” she said, noting that most patients with vulvar disorders are referred for pelvic floor therapy. “Almost all of them end up having pelvic floor dysfunction because the pelvic floor muscles spasm whenever there’s pain or inflammation.”

A Cautionary Word on Vulvodynia, and a Mast Cell Paradigm to Explore

Vulvodynia is defined as persistent pain of at least 3 months’ duration with no clear cause. “These are the patients with no skin findings,” Cigna said. But in most cases, she said, careful investigation identifies causes that are musculoskeletal, hormonal, or nerve-related.

“It’s a term that’s thrown around a lot — it’s kind of a catchall. Yet it should be a small minority of patients who truly have a diagnosis of vulvodynia,” she said.

In the early stages of investigation is the idea that mast cell proliferation and mast cell activation may play a role in some cases of vulvar and vestibular pain and itching. “We see that some patients with vulvodynia and vestibulodynia have mast cells that are increased in number in the epithelium and beneath the epithelium, and nerve staining shows an increased number of nerve endings traveling into the epithelium,” Cigna said.

“We do diagnose some people clinically” based on urticaria and other symptoms suggestive of mast cell proliferation/activation (such as flushing, abdominal cramping, diarrhea, hypotensive syncope or near syncope, and tachycardia), and “then we send them to the allergist for testing,” Cigna said.

Cigna and Murphy had no relevant financial disclosures.